And here's Part 2. I've checked the links, noting it on the dates, but this is still is just a basic re-posting from the original a few years ago.
Here we get into the specifics of Kwanzaa's Marxist principles, Ron Everett's... er, Maulana Karenga's sadistic torture of two black women, his mental issues, and some Kwanzaa websites' open call for a race war to create an African nation in America-- whatever that means.
Anyway, here you go:
The socialist (actually Marxist) nature of the seven principles, the Nguzo Saba,
of Kwanzaa is addressed, but once again dismissed by Riley. Of the seven
principles of Kwanzaa (unity, self-determination, collective work and
responsibility, cooperative economics, purpose, creativity, and faith), Riley
writes "The ujima [collective work and responsibility] and ujamaa [cooperative
economics] principles certainly sounds socialist, but any of the Kwanzaa
principles can be interpreted to mean that through private means we should help
others. I do think that these principles - if the focus is on private efforts,
and not Big Government - have merit year-round in building black
communities."
True enough. Who would have problems with the incredibly
general idea of "faith" or "creativity" etc.? I mean, how many anti-faith (not
necessarily religious faith-- faith here is used too generally for that) people
are out there? How many people are against creativity?
But the seven
principles of the Nguzo Saba were not created from an ideological vacuum, nor
have they evolved from centuries of social development, such as Christmas'
general "peace on Earth and goodwill toward men"-- a process that defines the
general principle with a cultural understanding and imbues it with a meaning
beyond the mere vague words. When scrutinized beyond the thinnest of superficial
gloss, it is evident (
from Karenga's own words UPDATED 12/10/10 & re-checked 12/27/13: *sigh*
Once again the link is down. You'd think that the works of Karenga would last
longer on the web than my tiny blog-- but no. Once again a search for these
quotes have come up empty.) that the seven principles, are, in fact, merely
Marxist principles created by Karenga for the expressed purpose of promoting
Marxist doctrine.
There is no question of Karenga's Marxism. He makes no
effort to hide his Marxism and openly promotes it. From Scholer: "Eight years
later [in 1989 according to the
wikipedia entry on Karenga] California State
University at Long Beach made Karenga the head of its Black Studies Department.
Karenga had toned down his rhetoric and abandoned his cultural nationalism for
straightforward Marxism." This "toned down" Marxism continued to be expressed in
the seven principles as detailed in the
Kawaida Theory: An African Communitarian
Philosophy, (
UPDATED 12/26/12 & rechecked 12/17/13
alas, this link is basically down. It's amazing to me how quickly these links
change) his book from 1980.
Karenga expounds on the intended principles
of the
Nguzu Saba here 1965 (
UPDATED 12/10/10 & still down in 12/27/13: This
link was to the same site as above and, as I said, it's down).
For Ujima
(collective work and responsibility) he writes, "The third principle encourages
self-criticism and personal evaluation, as it relates to the common good of the
family/community. Without collective work and struggle, progress is impossible.
The family and the community must accept the reality that we are collectively
responsible for our failures, as well as our victories and achievements.
Discussions concerning each family member's responsibility prove helpful in
defining and achieving family goals."
For Ujamaa (cooperative economics)
he writes, "Out of the fundamental concepts of 'African Communal Living' comes
the fourth principle of Kwanzaa. In a community or family, wealth and resources
should be shared. On the national level, cooperative economics can help
African-Americans take physical control of their own destinies. On this day,
ideas should be shared and discussed for cooperative economic efforts to provide
for needs as related to housing, education, food, day care, health,
transportation and other goods and services."
Let's see here... communal
living, collective work, and a fading of the individual through "self-criticism
and personal evaluation, as it relates to the common good of the
family/community" [I must add that this "self-evaluation" is a mainstay of
repressive communist regimes, particularly in the uber repressive North Korea
under Kim Il Sung]. I think it's perfectly reasonable to conclude that that an
avowed Marxist (cultural nationalist at the time) talking in these terms is
preaching to Marxist principles; therefore Ujima and Ujamaa do not just sound
socialist, they
are socialist.
When Karenga says Ujamaa
he meant specifically the definitions I quoted above. As the originator of
Kwanzaa, these are indisputably the specific meanings of Kwanzaa's founding,
generalized principles. So while Riley maintains that "any of the Kwanzaa
principles can be interpreted to mean that through private means we should help
others," she is presenting a mis-reading that is obvious once Karenga's writings
and theories are examined. If we are not a socialist or a Marxist, we should
look elsewhere for guiding principles to improve our communities.
Riley
tacitly acknowledges Karenga's violent history by writing "And while Maulana
Karenga’s history of abusing women is highly problematic, I believe that events
can transcend problematic founders (look at the Constitutional Convention in
Philadelphia back in 1787)." Again, an attempt to build an equivalency, in this
case between Karenga and the attendees of the Constitutional
Convention.
Rather than discuss in detail the myriad of differences
between Karenga and various members of the Constitutional Convention (men whose
births are separated by about two centuries), I will go into some detail about
Karenga's acknowledged abuse as publicly reported by the
Los Angeles
Times and related by Scholer.
"On September 17, 1971, Karenga was
sentenced to one to ten years in prison on counts of felonious assault and false
imprisonment. The charges stemmed from a May 9, 1970 incident in which Karenga
and two others tortured two women who Karenga believed had tried to kill him by
placing 'crystals' in his food and water.
"A year later the
Los
Angeles Times described the events: 'Deborah Jones, who once was given the
title of an African queen, said she and Gail Davis were whipped with an
electrical cord and beaten with a karate baton after being ordered to remove
their clothes. She testified that a hot soldering iron was placed in Miss Davis'
mouth and placed against Miss Davis' face and that one of her own big toes was
tightened in a vice. Karenga, head of US, also put detergent and running hoses
in their mouths, she said.'"
I'm sorry, but I don't believe that the
phrase "highly problematic" really does justice to the imprisonment, stripping,
binding, beating, burning, and the mangling of a toe during the systematic
torture of two women by Karenga and a pair of cohorts.
Karenga's sanity
can also be fairly questioned. Scholer again writes: "The shooting at UCLA [the
Jan. 17, 1969 killing of Black Panthers John Jerome Huggins and Alprentice
Carter by US Organization members George and Larry Stiner immediately following
Huggins' and Carter's verbal attack of Karenga during a public meeting] caused
Karenga to become deeply paranoid and spurred his bizarre behavior. At his
trial, the question of Karenga's sanity arose. The psychiatrist's report stated,
'This man now represents a picture which can be considered both paranoid and
schizophrenic with hallucinations and elusions, inappropriate affect,
disorganization, and impaired contact with the environment.' The psychiatrist
observed that Karenga talked to his blanket and imaginary persons and believed
that he had been attacked by dive-bombers."
While it is, perhaps, true
that at times "events can transcend problematic founders," Karenga's problems,
to me, are an awful lot to transcend.
And of course, this begs the
question as to what an event will become once it transcends its founder. Would
Kwanzaa become transformed into something more then a racially divisive,
anti-religious, Marxist promoting event?
As I wrote in part 1 of this post, as Kwanzaa became more popular within
mainstream Black American communities, Karenga backed down from his virulently
anti-religious bent. As I stated before, Karenga's newer books like
Kwanzaa:
A Celebration of Family, Community, and Culture (1997) tell lies
(contradicted by Karenga's earlier works) about Kwanzaa not being intended as an
alternative to Christian holidays.
But this inauthentic backing away from
its anti-religious roots has not been coupled with Kwanzaa backing away from the
radical black separatist movement. At least none is in evidence at the Official
Kwanzaa Information Center as Scholer, once again, points out. "Still, some
charge that the holiday and its official black, green, and red flag promotes
racial separatism and violence. Says the official Kwanzaa Information Center:
'red, or the blood, stands as the top of all things. We lost our land through
blood; and we cannot gain it except through blood. We must redeem our lives
through the blood. Without the shedding of blood there can be no redemption of
this race.' The Kwanzaa Information Center also notes that the flag 'has become
the symbol of devotion for African people in America to establish an independent
African nation on the North American Continent.'"
Okay... So the
official Kwanzaa Information Center (
UPDATED 12/10/10 & 12/26/12 &12/27/13: The site this link is
to is no longer the "official" Kwanzaa Information Center-- gosh, a lot changes
in a year. It is now simply the Kwanzaa Information Center. The Official Kwanzaa
Website [at least according to its web address]
is here and gives pretty much the
watered-down, family-friendly schtick-- among the ample links for making a
donation.) is basically calling for a race war --the shedding of blood to redeem
the race etc.-- not unlike white supremacists. Great. Actually the quote
Scholder mentions is from the
"Feel Good Information" section (I am not
making this up) of the Kwanzaa Information Center's website. The quote regarding
the Black Nationalist flag in full is:
"Origin of the Flag of Pan-Africanism and/or
Black Nationalism Red is for the Blood. Black is the Black People. Green is for
the Land.
"Red, Black and Green are the oldest national colors known to
man. They are used as the flag of the Black Liberation Movement in America
today, but actually go back to the Zinj Empires of ancient Africa, which existed
thousands of years before Rome, Greece, France, England or America.
"The
Red, or the blood, stands as the top of all things. We lost our land through
blood; and we cannot gain it except through blood. We must redeem our lives
through the blood. Without the shedding of blood there can be no redemption of
this race. However, the bloodshed and sorrow will not last always. The Red
significantly stands in our flag as a reminder of the truth of history, and that
men must gain and keep their liberty, even at the risk of bloodshed.
"The
Black is in the middle. The Black man in this hemisphere has yet to obtain land
which is represented by the Green. The acquisition of land is the highest and
noblest aspiration for the Black man on this continent, since without land there
can be no freedom, justice, independence, or equality."
A little further
down the page is the "devotion for African people in America to establish an
independent African nation on the North American Continent" part as related by
Scholer.
For an event to transcend the problematic founders, paraphrasing
Riley, the event must move beyond both the faults and the intentions of the
founder. If we were to peel away from Kwanzaa the racial exclusivity of the
black separatism, the anti-religious ardor, the rituals designed to replace
Christmas celebrations, the Marxist doctrines contained within the Nguzo Saba's
seven principles, all of this imbued by its angry founder Karenga-- what's
left?
I understand that Riley was somewhat ambivalent to Kwanzaa and that
the very short blurb was not intended as an endorsement of the "holiday." I have
nothing against Shay Riley. I have never met Riley, never (to my knowledge) have
read anything else written by Riley, and this very long posting was not meant,
in any way, to be an attack against Riley personally.
But Riley's
ambivalence is something very common, and found both in my own and my wife's
family. There's a real lack of understanding regarding the fringe origins of
Kwanzaa. The idea seems to be that if Hallmark makes Kwanzaa cards, the holiday
must be legitimate and not a bad thing. My family shies away from scrutinizing
"black things" (best to leave it all alone) and my wife's family generally give
black opinions, theories, and views (no matter how wild or fantastic) their
quick approval and then an almost completely unearned pass. I don't think
there's anyone in either branches of my family that would support Kwanzaa after
learning the facts about its origins and creator.
Kwanzaa is founded on
principles that are incompatible with today's mores and unacceptable by
mainstream America's current values-- mores and values resulting from the many
years of struggles for civil rights.
Kwanzaa champions racial separation,
segregation, anger, and meaningless racial confrontation while rejecting racial
integration and downplaying interracial understanding and tolerance.
It
attacks religion rather than respects it-- uses outlandish language and
concocted suppositions to coerce a needless and artificial racial
confrontation.
Kwanzaa's seven principles sacrifice the rights of the
individual upon a Marxist altar-- for the sake of communal work, collective
economics, and sacrifice of self, all designed to help control Black American
individuals and bring them into a black separatist fold-- making them think
"correctly."
Kwanzaa was founded by a radical and violent black
nationalist; a man who was convicted of personally participating in the
atrocious tortures of two black women, as well being very closely (if not
directly) linked to the1969 murders of two members of the Black
Panthers.
Kwanzaa is a contrived, artificial, and inauthentic holiday
championing anger and alienation. It is nothing to celebrate.
UPDATE 12/27/13: Oh great...
According to Jerome Hudson, the
RNC released a "Happy Kwanzaa" statement. Nice job fellas. Way to do some research.
No comments:
Post a Comment